Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Hello and welcome everybody to the Annuity Straight Talk podcast, episode number 244.
[00:00:06] My name is Brian Andersen, founder and creator of AnnuityStraightTalk.com I am getting ready to leave Kansas. I've been here for the past two weeks. I'm going to record this truck's behind me. I'm going to load up. Got a nice white tail, some really good sausage and steaks and all that stuff.
[00:00:22] Ready to go back to Montana. Going to drop this and then hit the road and travel over the weekend.
[00:00:28] Please like subscribe or comment on any of your favorite podcast platforms or on YouTube. Send me an email.
[00:00:34] Do it on the website.
[00:00:36] Just let me know what you think. And if you have any questions that pertain to any of this stuff. It's good time for a lesson right now if you want to make an appointment with me, it's the top right corner of any page on annuitiestraighttalk.com serving up only the best annuities and best strategies for retirement. Happy to help whoever needs it. So I want to talk today about underperforming annuity indexes. This has been a topic with a lot of my clients because we, you know, we got the index, annuities and all that stuff. And some of the, some of them are coming through a year when the market is up and not returning all that well. So we understand the mechanics behind that is we're going to talk about. And with all the chaos happening in the market, it seems to be a good time for a lesson on the basics. Now, this is not the first time I've said this, but everyone needs to understand you don't ever hear this anywhere else. And I'm really surprised at some of my really smart clients. There's nobody else advising them that talks to them about the mechanics and the fundamentals of investments and how things work. So a lot of people get it wrong. And it kind of surprises me that no other financial professionals are teaching this to clients. But interest rates affect overall portfolio performance regardless of the correction in the market in the past few weeks. Bonds inside a portfolio have lost money over the past year.
[00:01:54] If you hold the bond itself, the market value of that drop as rates rise. Now, you're still getting your interest payments, but if you have to liquidate that, then you take a hit. So your overall portfolio is going to look smaller. So that's usually the hedge against drops in the market. Right.
[00:02:10] But a drop in the value of the bond is going to basically decrease the overall portfolio value. Okay. If stocks rise, you make Money, but you lose a little money because the bond values drop. So in the past year, when the market was up 14, 15, if your bonds were down 10, 12%, then the overall portfolio doesn't achieve that great yield, which is a lot of people think, oh, well, the market's up 20%. I must have made 20%. Well, not if you're blending in stock bonds. It doesn't always work that way. Okay, this is relevant to index annuities because a lot of the indexes that show incredible past performance. I've talked about this on a couple of episodes. You understand, I gotta understand the fundamentals of why those indexes return so high in the past or project historically to do so well is because of interest rates. I've got two podcasts out there about this. So if you want to look at those and you want to understand what blended indexes look like, then go check that out so you can go talk about. I did crazy annuity indexes that shows, like the crazy numbers, why they appear to be that way. And then volatility control indexes, which talk about essentially an index that has a bond component in order to control the volatility. And in the past year, the market was up. Those indexes, like say, NASDAQ was one that was up really high. And a NASDAQ blended index would have a muted return because the volatility control mechanism was a bond, and those bonds lost value. And so people were coming through the year and getting, you know, when the market was up, they would still come down 0%, 1%, 2%, something like that. It's kind of like, wait a second, market's up, why didn't I make money? Well, it's a blended portfolio in there, just like an investment portfolio. Now, I always say, as long as we can explain it, understand why it happens, then we can identify the times when it is either favorable or unfavorable to participate in a certain index.
[00:04:02] But I'm not just going to go back on back testing, say, oh, look how great this does. A lot of people get into trouble when they look at projections and think, you have to wonder what economic factors existed at the time and what is the likelihood that those will repeat themselves in the future? Okay, now, annuities with index annuities with allocations strictly on the S&P 500, or an equity index with no risk control mechanism did very well because there's no other component affecting the yield. It's straight up, hey, what did the index do?
[00:04:31] So I have to remind people that these work exactly like A blended investment. So this is just again, a lesson on the fundamentals of how a portfolio works. The only way to get the full return in the market is to be 100% invested in equities. Some people do that, but most do not.
[00:04:47] When you have a standard bond allocation and rates rise, you lose some of the money on that part of the portfolio.
[00:04:53] So it's going to bring down the total return even if your stock side is up. And the same as with the annuity, Right? So people that see the safety of annuity, little to no return on a blended index may not be so bad when you look at everything. If you had a conservative investment portfolio, if you were bond heavy, then you would have seen a big drop in your portfolio value.
[00:05:16] Aside from that. So you're looking for security that 0 to 1, 1 to 3%. Something like that is better than buying a bond that lost 10% of its value, right?
[00:05:27] So now that the market is down well over 10% from its top end, it really stings for an investment portfolio. Now, the point of using annuities is to reduce volatility. And I don't really like to see 0% returns either, but if you keep it in perspective, it's better than the alternative. So myga owners are looking really good right now with solid gains and no volatility, no fees, nothing.
[00:05:50] Many index annuity owners have done just fine. We're going to have some resets coming up soon that won't catch the market because it's dropped quite a bit. And I can't remember exactly where it was last year, but it has been up, you know, 15% or so this year. So I imagine we'll see what happens with the rebound in the market. Right now, I'm not saying you should choose an annuity over stocks, but I think you should seriously consider avoiding bonds because you don't have the consistency and it's really tough to build a big portfolio. A lot of times you're in bond funds, and bond funds continuously trade, so you see a wildly fluctuating value over time.
[00:06:23] So true security and optimal growth are much easier with limited volatility. Now, of course, you can try to time the purchase of bonds. If you own a bond and interest rates drop, then you have a significant increase in value. But then selling it to capture that gain means you're replacing it with a lower rate. Okay, that kind of works out. You're going to get burned eventually. People try it, but not everybody does. And again, in retirement, you want some stability, you know, some assurances that You've got, you know, stability when the market is, is volatile and interest rates included. Okay? Now, if I would have known that rates were going to rise in the past. I remember last year the Fed was cutting rates. Okay? The Fed does not control annuity rates. They talk about raising rates. That might change with the market taking a pretty significant hit in a couple weeks.
[00:07:13] But people say, should I wait until the Fed decision? They might. Well, let's remember last year they were cutting rates and annuity rates came up. It does not happen. It's a function of the market and kind of supply and demand and where money is flowing. If it's risk off and a lot of people diving into Treasuries, you usually see rates pull back. If everybody wants it, they're not going to pay you so much. When the market's running, the rates kind of go up too, because nobody wants it. So to issue debt, they've got to offer a higher rate to entice people to do it. Okay? Inflation has continued to climb and the Fed is talking about raising interest rates. Who knows?
[00:07:49] Things may be put on hold with a little pullback in the market. We don't know. Interest rates are still solid. You can expect them to stay volatile and in the foreseeable future.
[00:07:58] I wish we had consistency, but that's just not the market. That's why we do planning. That's why we look for security, that's why we look for guaranteed income and all those things. Okay? No matter what, do not let the daily fluctuations get you in a hurry. Again, I'm not trying to scare anybody or talk about this. If you're prepared, then it doesn't matter, right?
[00:08:17] Look at all the factors that limit yield and reduce risk wherever you can. I'm still seeing some of the best annuity deals I've, I've, I've ever seen in my career. That's almost 24 years. Right back to, like my early days of selling fixed annuities. In 2004, 5 and 6, we had 6% yields, pretty easy to get. And now you're seeing it again and, you know, I had one person, you know, rates like, I think nationwide went from 6.05 on a Myga down to 5.95. And somebody said, oh, I really want more than six. It's like, okay, and maybe you'll get it. But like, how often you seen that? I don't know, not for 20 plus years. So I don't know what to tell you to do, except if you're going to go into annuity we're going to make sure that you get the best deal, you know, time and terms and all that stuff. Okay. If you want to look into the options, this is a great time to do it. If you're talking about retirement planning, don't forget we've got a portfolio application where we can test an annuity and portfolio, either fixed or an income annuity, to show you how that affects the overall return. In the past, it makes a big difference when you're drawing money from a portfolio. Right. So. But if you want to talk to me, I'd be happy to go over in your situation and again, just have a, have a reasonable discussion. I'm not going to force you to do anything you don't want to do. I'm just going to explain the reasons why it might be beneficial and teach you about the products so that you can do whatever it is you do with the most confidence possible. Okay.
[00:09:39] I'm going to hit the road here in a couple hours. I appreciate you guys joining me. Cool story about why I come to Kansas. A really good friend of mine bought a ranch 20. I met him 21 years ago in Alaska. He said, I bought a ranch. This is in 2010. Bought a ranch. You can always come hunting if you want. He's a very successful guy. When I was guiding up in Alaska, we became friends and he kind of said, hey, I could afford to go to those expensive lodges, but I want to learn how to do it. I want to learn to do what you do. And so we've done a lot of really cool wilderness trips in Montana, Alaska, done some adventure stuff. And it's just simple things like getting the right kind of firewood, building the fire, cooking over the fire. I'm a very good camp cook, by the way. And so he's just become a very, very good friend. And we've done a lot of fun stuff together. And he liked it because he said, well, it's just everybody that's in, you know, his group of, group of friends, they just, you know, they pay outfitters, they do this. He said, that's fun and it's great. I've done that a little bit too. But he really wanted to get to learn how to do it and so I helped them figure it out. Anyhow, this has been episode 244 underperforming annuity indexes. It's just like a blended portfolio, right? Bonds dropping in value will affect an investment portfolio as well. Within the index annuities, we saw some, you know, suboptimal returns when the market was running, but that's the point of having them. And again, better than the alternative of losing money in a bond portfolio. So thank you guys so much for joining me. I'll be on my way back home to Montana over the weekend and in the office on Monday. You want to make an appointment, it's the top right corner of any page on annuitystraighttalk.com, thank you so much for joining me. You guys have a great week and I will talk to you soon. Okay, bye.